Today, the exhilaration Homeland defense (DHS) secretary is in Texas’s Rio Grande valley to storage what the Trump management is hailing as a milestone: 400 mile of brand-new border wall construction due to the fact that Trump’s January 2017 inauguration. As the administration celebrates this “achievement,” we have to take a clear-eyed look in ~ this i have lot of money boondoggle. It has become a monument to failure, xenophobia, human being rights abuse, and environmental damage—and the must get taken down expeditiously.

As of October 19, U.S. Customs and Border defense (CBP) to be reporting that 371 miles of brand-new wall had actually been built. Using data indigenous a continual CBP condition update, us conclude that, the those 371 miles:

16 were built where no fencing existed before;about 170 were built where just “vehicle barrier” (structures that can block a auto but not someone on foot) exist before;about 135 were developed to replace older, much shorter fencing; and50 miles are brand-new or replacement “secondary wall” constructed parallel come existing fencing.

You are watching: How much of trump’s wall has been built

As that status update indicates, this has actually been built—and continues to it is in built—at a cost of around $15 exchange rate in 2017-2020 funds. (Our ideal current calculation is $15.067 billion.) 70 percent of the money was not approved by the U.S. Congress, as our constitution dictates. Together in-depth in January, Donald trump wrested most of that from the Defense Department’s spending plan by advertising a “national emergency.”

It seems ridiculous even to need to point this out, yet not a dime the this has been paid by Mexico, as Donald Trump continues to falsely declare, no one is there any kind of plan to recuperate the money, whether with tariffs, border-crossing fees, or any other mechanism. The U.S. Taxpayer has constructed these 400 miles at a projected price of $20.4 million every mile. Even without expense overruns, that’s virtually $70 from every U.S. Household.

Much that this building and construction required the administration to waive dozens that laws protecting the environment, historical sites, native American lands, and also proper bureaucratic procedure. The genuine ID Act, which permitted existing laws to be pushed aside for obstacle construction, has actually been invoked 31 times since its 2005 passage; 26 that those have developed since 2017.

DHS and its building contractors have been racing to develop as much wall surface as feasible before Trump’s term ends, hitting a speed of an ext than a mile every day. Lot of this building has been in terrain whereby it is straightforward to rack up huge mileage: flat, government-owned land in the deserts that Arizona and brand-new Mexico. Together the wall Street newspaper noted, much of this terrain is far desert “where illegal border crossings have been relatively low in current years.”

These are locations where couple of people cross, and where, because of their remoteness, the wall doesn’t pose much of an obstacle to crossers. “A wall may slow someone under for the 10-15 minute it take away to rise over, yet those 10-15 minutes barely influence a border crosser’s head start in rural border areas,” observed in 2018. And walls are specifically useless when, as has actually been the case since 2014, countless if not most apprehended migrants are human being seeking simply to collection foot on U.S. Soil and also be arrest in order to petition because that asylum or protection.

The Damage

There is nothing come celebrate around the border wall surface construction. there is no proof to imply that the wall improved protection or deterred migrants. It has actually wasted resources while law incalculable damage to human rights, our mechanism of checks and also balances, and also border communities and also ecosystems. 

The damage has environmental harm. Construction, enabled by lot of waivers that the Endangered varieties Act, is cutting turn off migratory corridors because that jaguars, ocelots, black bears, bighorn sheep, coati, hill lions, javelina, raccoons, hooded skunks, mule deer, and smaller species. It has destroyed countless decades-old saguaro cacti on nationwide parkland. The is harming fragile, scarce freshwater sources like the Quitobaquito oasis in Arizona’s body organ Pipe nationwide Monument—home come unique varieties of turtle and also fish and also being drained, via surrounding wells, to mix cement for wall surface foundations—and the mountain Pedro flow in southeast Arizona, one of the largest undammed rivers remaining in the southwest unified States. Wall surfaces will catch debris during monsoon desert rains, risking flooding that might even uproot the obstacle itself. Meanwhile, dynamiting and comparable demolition are recurring in the nearby Guadalupe Canyon region, forever gouging scars into stunning, rugged landscape that was currently impenetrable come border crossers. In Texas, wall surface construction threatens to torpedo a 40-year initiative to consolidate a reduced Rio Grande valley Wildlife Refuge.

The damage consists of harm to native American society and communities. As construction crews have approached their lands, the Tohono O’odham in Arizona and also the Kumeyaay in California—both of who lands expectations the border—have staged several recent protests, consisting of acts of civil disobedience and some arrests. The Quitobaquito feather is a sacred genealogical site because that the O’odham, and also there are numerous archeological web page in the wall’s path. The Kumeyaay have actually filed suit to avoid the desecration that sacred interment sites. All of this building required DHS to waive regulations protecting indigenous lands, and there was no coherent attempt to consult with indigenous American communities about construction plans.

The damage contains harm to home rights. In Texas, whereby the border follows the Rio Grande because that 1,200 miles, the bulk of floor abutting the river is privately held: almost 1,000 landowners was standing in the wall’s potential path. The Trump management has aggressively launched eminent domain procedures to seize this land in bespeak to construct fencing. This has actually meant submit suits versus middle-class residents, some of whom have held your plots for generations, versus an orphanage in Laredo, and has sped up the pace of litigation throughout the pandemic.

The damage includes unnecessary and preventable deaths of migrants. since the 1990s, barrier construction has channeled lot undocumented migration to segments of the border far-off from population centers, choose deserts and also ranchlands. In this treacherous territories, well over 7,000 have died on U.S. Soil, mainly of dehydration and also exposure, throughout this century. An ext fencing will certainly mean much more diversion to this areas, and recovered stays hit a seven-year high in Arizona throughout the 2020 fiscal year. The new, 30-foot-high wall surface can likewise be deadly as soon as migrants are desperate enough to climb it. is conscious of two cases of women, among them pregnant, that perished near El Paso in 2020 of falls from atop the wall.

The damage has harm to relationships with neighbors to the south. noted in 2018, “The border wall sends a hostile blog post to allies in Latin America. The wall surface would carry a steep diplomatic cost, an especially in U.S. Relationships with Mexico. It would certainly detract indigenous international cooperation needed come fight against drug trafficking, terrorism, and other issues.” it did and continues to do so. Tensions around the border wall were a primary reason why mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto paid no visits to Washington because that bilateral meetings throughout his last two years in office. As long as it stands, Trump’s wall sends a message that the United states would rather wall surface off Latin America than job-related with the an ar to confront multilateral challenges; that the United states believes Latin America is inferior. 

The damage includes harm to our democracy and rule of law. The U.S. Constitution offers Congress the power of the purse. The president, unequal a king, cannot spend taxpayers’ money there is no the approval of citizens’ representatives. In so late 2018 and also early 2019, in spite of partially shutting down the U.S. Federal government for 35 days, Donald Trump failed to to convince the U.S. Congress to appropriate more than a base level that $1.375 exchange rate for wall surface construction. Instead, he explicitly went versus the will certainly of congress by heralding a “national emergency.” he has due to the fact that raided at least $9.9 exchange rate from the Defense Department’s budget to pay for most of what has actually been built.

This is a stunning distortion the the 1976 nationwide Emergencies Act, which allows a president to carry funds in impressive circumstances. This law gives Congress the capacity to challenge the emergency declaration every 6 months, by passing a joint resolution. A 1983 can be fried Court decision permits the president to veto this resolution; the emergency declaration would certainly then stay in place unless two-thirds that both houses of Congress poll to override the veto. Double in 2019, conference passed joint resolutions to take down Trump’s emergency declaration. Both times, trumped vetoed the resolutions. Both times strong majorities, consisting of 26 Republican representatives and senators, voted to override the veto—but they did not reach the important two-thirds. The emergency declarations challenge court difficulties working their method through the commonwealth judiciary, but the can be fried Court has allowed wall-building to proceed while the justice gears continue to grind.

As the Republican dissenters—most of them Appropriations Committee members—noted, the border wall surface emergency declaration to be an authoritarian appropriate of congressional power. 

The damages includes feasible improprieties in contracting. A July 2020 report indigenous the DHS Inspector-General states that the department “did not usage a sound, well-documented methodology come identify and also prioritize invest in areas along the border that would best benefit from physics barriers.” In other words, in its rush to construct the wall as fast as possible, while waiving regulations governing bureaucratic procedure, the Trump management increased the risk that taxpayers’ money would be invested wastefully.

We’ve watched much proof of garbage in the hiring of private building firms to construct the wall. A new ProPublica examination revealed that “more 보다 200 contract modifications, at time awarded within just weeks or months after the initial contracts,” have actually increased the price of building by $2.9 billion over the contracts’ original amount. At $20.4 million per mile, the Trump-era wall surface is about five times more expensive 보다 that developed during the Bush and Obama administrations.

Questions specifically surround among the contractors, north Dakota-based Fisher Industries, whose president, Tommy Fisher, is one energetic backer that the chairman who has praised that in regular Fox News appearances. V cronyistic ties to Trump’s associates, Fisher “has upended the commonwealth procurement process to come to be Trump’s go-to builder in ~ the border,” together The Washington post put it, winning over $2 exchange rate in wall-building contracts. The Defense room Inspector general has to be auditing among those contracts, valued at $400 million, since December. 

The president’s pet wall-building task is doing tragic damages on countless fronts.

See more: How Much Is A Book Deal : The Complete Process, Understanding Book Advances And Royalties

that does no make united state safer. It will certainly go down as a monument come populist lies, come xenophobia, and also to unaddressed flaws in our autonomous system. Regardless of the result of the November 2020 election, the joined States should take down this monument come failure, starting with the segment that carry out the best harm to the environment, to aboriginal American communities, to exclusive property holders, and to our identity as a great neighbor that offers fair, due procedure to those seek protection.